Summary
Section #7.1: What is Political Identity?
Political identity consists of the traits and beliefs that make us who we are, from gender to religion to ethnicity to political affiliation. Understanding different political identities is critical to any analysis of political systems. Imagine trying to comprehend politics in the United States without some sense of who identifies as “conservative” and who identifies as “progressive”. Political identity is as complex and as nuanced as it is essential to the study of comparative politics.
Section #7.2: What is National Identity?
National identity is how we see ourselves as members of a nation of people. This can range from a relatively narrow ethnic identity to a broader civic identity that encompasses many ethnic and religious groups. It can be inclusive or exclusive and not all people will define it the same way, even within the same country. National identity also informs nationalist separatist movements as well as policies about citizenship.
Section #7.3: What is Religious Identity?
Religious identity, rooted in family and community, is how one thinks of themselves as belonging to a religious group. Religious identity is measured using the “four B’s”: Believing, Belonging, Behaving, and Bonding. Like national identity, religious identity can be a centralizing force leading to unity or a decentralizing force leading to exclusionary behavior or conflict. There is some debate about whether religious identity can come before the formation of a specific religion. Religious identity is not bound by geography, yet the intensity of religious identity - and its influence on politics - does vary across different countries.
Section #7.4: What is Class Identity?
Class identity has two main components: economic and social. Economic class is about a person’s relative income and/or wealth in society. It is easier to measure and define than social class, though it is not always easy to see. Economic class is about power. Social class can be tied to or independent of economic class. Typically, those of high economic class also have high social status. Yet, social class, because it is about how highly a person is respected and how well-connected they are in their society. The subjective nature of social class means it varies across cultures and countries.
Section #7.5: Comparative case study - Israel and Iran: The Intersection of Politics and Identity
Using the Most Different Systems approach, we can see that the independent variable in Israel and Iran are political outcomes that favor religion (though the dominant religion is different in each case). The dependent variable, then, is the power of one religion on the politics of each country. Some control variables include: type of government, economic policy, secularization, cooperation with the West, and socioeconomic indicators.
Review Questions
- What are the components of political identity?
- Ethnicity and religion
- Gender and class
- Ideology and nationality
- All of these
- How does understanding political identity relate to the study of comparative politics?
- Political identity helps us understand and analyze political movements and systems
- Political identity helps us understand why all wealthy people are conservatives
- Political identity is a constant, rather than a variable, in studying comparative politics
- What are the 4 “B’s of religious identity?
- Believing, Belonging, Behaving and Bonding
- Believing, Beholding, Behaving, Bonding
- Bonding, Behaving, Belonging, Bending
- Behaving, Binding, Believing, Beholding
- What political outcomes help demonstrate the dominance of Judaism in Israel and Shia Islam in Iran?
- Legal codes that favor each group
- Judicial system that includes religious courts
- Favoritism and preferences for religious students and religious education
- The role of religious parties and factions in each country’s political system
- All of these answers are correct
- What is an example of political identity in Iran?
- The importance of the Iranian Revolution
- The inclusion of Kurds in Iranian politics
- The exclusion of religion as part of Iranian identity
Answers: 1.d, 2.a, 3.a, 4.e, 5.a